I think Brave was more a “disappointing by Pixar standards” than an overall disappointing film, most reviews were still positive.
My personal order would be: Brave, Usual Suspects, Ted, ???, Bourne Legacy, Jaws.
Brave is a Pixar film and will draw in the crowds as a headliner. Then, if Usual Suspects is rather cerebrally heavy, it’d be better to have it earlier up the line-up. Follow it up with Ted, which will be a nice breather and relative no-brainer. Mystery… I predict Justin Bieber: Never Say Never, just saying. Bourne Legacy is mostly an action film, doesn’t require a lot of thinking and if it’s not great, well nobody’s paying a great deal of attention in 5th. Jaws is Jaws, 'nuff said.
The only other order I can think of would be: Brave, Bourne Legacy, Ted, ???, 10 Things I Hate About You, Jaws. (Order of Bourne Legacy and Ted up for debate.)
If we do want the newest films front and center, and Usual Suspects really is that tricky to follow, maybe that’s the one we should switch out. I understand if not, I just think that it might work as a radical alternative.